McClatchy DC Logo

Commentary: More dignified treatment for detained immigrants | McClatchy Washington Bureau

×
    • Customer Service
    • Mobile & Apps
    • Contact Us
    • Newsletters
    • Subscriber Services

    • All White House
    • Russia
    • All Congress
    • Budget
    • All Justice
    • Supreme Court
    • DOJ
    • Criminal Justice
    • All Elections
    • Campaigns
    • Midterms
    • The Influencer Series
    • All Policy
    • National Security
    • Guantanamo
    • Environment
    • Climate
    • Energy
    • Water Rights
    • Guns
    • Poverty
    • Health Care
    • Immigration
    • Trade
    • Civil Rights
    • Agriculture
    • Technology
    • Cybersecurity
    • All Nation & World
    • National
    • Regional
    • The East
    • The West
    • The Midwest
    • The South
    • World
    • Diplomacy
    • Latin America
    • Investigations
  • Podcasts
    • All Opinion
    • Political Cartoons

  • Our Newsrooms

Opinion

Commentary: More dignified treatment for detained immigrants

Daniel Shoer Roth - El Nuevo Herald

    ORDER REPRINT →

March 20, 2009 03:42 AM

She spent days lying in the jail cell's cot "stiff as a corpse," with pain in her joints that demanded medical attention. The symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis were unbearable, but the prison guards gave her no pity.

Several weeks passed at the Monroe County Jail and Lourdes wasn't given any of the nine medications she needs to treat her severe arthritis. Her jailers justified it by saying that they had to get permission from Immigration and Customs Enforcement. As far as they were concerned, Lourdes was just another immigrant to be deported.

"I felt humiliated, trampled, because apart from not providing the treatment, the officials treat you with cruelty, inhumanely, and that affects you more than the pain," recalled the 49-year-old Hispanic woman, between sobs. Lourdes, who lives in Miami, asked that her real name not be used because her case is pending.

Her testimony is part of a report released Tuesday by the Florida Immigrant Advocacy Center about the precarious – and often nonexistent – medical services provided to immigrants at federal detention centers, state prisons and county jails.

SIGN UP

"ICE tolerates a culture of cruelty and indifference to human suffering," states the FIAC report. "Detainees routinely report being treated as criminals, being accused of faking illnesses and having painful symptoms ignored."

The United States stands up for human rights throughout the world. What if we started leading by example and treated detained immigrants with dignity? Right now, they are not even extended the same rights conferred to criminals in state and federal prisons.

Lourdes arrived over 20 years ago from Latin America and was given political asylum. A year later, she became a legal resident. She was followed by her husband and children. Her grandkids are U.S. citizens.

She worked tirelessly, cleaning hotel rooms and offices, leaving for work at 7 a.m. and returning at midnight, barely time to speak to her kids.

A few years ago, she was convicted of minor infractions that did not warrant jail time, her lawyers said without elaborating. But last year, while returning from a trip to her homeland, she was detained at Miami International Airport. She was given a summons to appear at the ICE office. That day, she was detained.

For three years, she had been taking nine medications for arthritis and could walk with only slight pain. Three months after her ICE detention, she was released in a wheelchair and had lost 60 pounds.

Today, she still relies on a walker. She is swollen and her feet are atrophied. Her rheumatologist at Jackson Memorial Hospital says her current condition is "potentially irreversible."

Lourdes says it wasn't until she was unable to walk or bathe that her jailers provided her with a wheelchair. Only then was she given "medicine:" folic acid and iron. "I felt that I would die, because they didn't pay me any attention. I had to swallow my pain."

Lourdes isn't a terrorist, but this wife, mother and grandmother was mistreated as if she deserved death.

Newly appointed Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, whose agency oversees ICE, should read the findings of this latest report and insist on humanitarian treatment for people waiting for their cases to be resolved. Otherwise, we mock the human rights that we demand the rest of the world to uphold.

ABOUT THE WRITER

Daniel Shoer Roth is a columnist at El Nuevo Herald, where he has worked since 1999. He writes about issues that affect South Floridians but do not get enough public attention.

Related stories from McClatchy DC

HOMEPAGE

More columns by Daniel Shoer Roth

March 19, 2009 01:50 PM

  Comments  

Videos

“It’s not mine,” Pompeo says of New York Times op-ed

Trump and Putin shake hands at G20 Summit

View More Video

Trending Stories

Justice declines to pursue allegations that CIA monitored Senate Intel staff

July 10, 2014 12:02 PM

RIP Medical Debt donation page

November 05, 2018 05:11 PM

Trump’s prison plan to release thousands of inmates

December 21, 2018 12:18 PM

Trump administration wants huge limits on food stamps — even though Congress said ‘no’

December 20, 2018 05:00 AM

Jerry Moran to push for speedy final vote on ending U.S. role in Yemen

December 11, 2018 01:21 PM

Read Next

A preview of 2019 and a few New Year’s resolutions for Trump and Pelosi

Opinion

A preview of 2019 and a few New Year’s resolutions for Trump and Pelosi

By Andrew Malcolm Special to McClatchy

    ORDER REPRINT →

January 02, 2019 06:00 AM

The president might resolve to keep his mouth shut some and silencing his cellphone more this year. Pelosi too could work on her public speaking and maybe use notes a bit more to remind of the subject at hand.

KEEP READING

MORE OPINION

The West has long militarized space. China plans to weaponize it. Not good.

Opinion

The West has long militarized space. China plans to weaponize it. Not good.

December 27, 2018 04:52 PM
Trump’s artless deal: The president’s Syria decision will have long-term consequences

Opinion

Trump’s artless deal: The president’s Syria decision will have long-term consequences

December 26, 2018 06:00 AM
This is not what Vladimir Putin wanted for Christmas

Opinion

This is not what Vladimir Putin wanted for Christmas

December 20, 2018 05:12 PM
The solution to the juvenile delinquency problem in our nation’s politics

Opinion

The solution to the juvenile delinquency problem in our nation’s politics

December 18, 2018 06:00 AM
High-flying U.S. car execs often crash when when they run into foreign laws

Opinion

High-flying U.S. car execs often crash when when they run into foreign laws

December 13, 2018 06:09 PM
Putin wants to divide the West. Can Trump thwart his plan?

Opinion

Putin wants to divide the West. Can Trump thwart his plan?

December 11, 2018 06:00 AM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

McClatchy Washington Bureau App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Newsletters
Learn More
  • Customer Service
  • Securely Share News Tips
  • Contact Us
Advertising
  • Advertise With Us
Copyright
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story