As President Donald Trump prepares to address Congress on Tuesday for the first time, a new McClatchy-Marist Poll finds that even 72 percent of Trump’s own supporters want a path to citizenship for immigrants who are in the U.S. illegally.
Trump is targeting millions of people for possible deportation. But Americans are warm to the notion that immigrants should be welcome.
“The White House is clearly not in step with where public opinion is on this question,” said Lee Miringoff, director of the Marist College Institute for Public Opinion, which conducted the nationwide survey.
Christopher Harwell, a 31-year-old Trump supporter from Columbia, South Carolina, said it was important to him that people in the country illegally paid a fine. If they do, he sees no problem with offering a chance at citizenship.
“If they get fined, then they would be paying the consequences,” Harwell said. “We as Americans have to do the same thing when we get in trouble, when we break the law.”
Eighty percent of all Americans want Congress to give immigrants who are in the U.S. illegally a chance at citizenship if they learn English, pay fines and have jobs that pay taxes, according to the nationwide survey.
Trump is consumed with building a wall on the Mexican border and cracking down on illegal immigration through increased deportations. He’s made no attempt to offer a path to citizenship for those who are in the country illegally.
Miringoff said his polling often found Trump’s positions opposed by Americans as a whole but supported by a majority of Republicans. This time it’s different, with 69 percent of Republicans in favor of offering a path to citizenship.
“What is startling is the gap between what Republicans and Trump supporters think on this question and the position and direction the White House is taking,” he said.
Trump is expected to bring up immigration in his highly anticipated address to Congress on Tuesday.
A bipartisan group of senators called the “Gang of Eight” proposed a bill in 2013 to give immigrants living illegally in the U.S. the chance to apply for citizenship after paying a fine and back taxes. The bill, which passed the Senate with a bipartisan majority but went nowhere in the House of Representatives, would have also authorized a border security buildup.
Trump is against the bill, according to the White House, and he criticizes what he calls “amnesty” for illegal immigration. But senators who met with the president this month suggested he was interested in learning more about the Gang of Eight effort.
Republicans welcome that approach. “We depend on a lot of these immigrants for a lot of jobs, services, in our country and I think we need some path to citizenship,” said Keith Williston, a 38-year-old Republican from Independence, Missouri. “Now getting one that’s going to work well, I’m not holding my breath for that.”
Eighty-seven percent of Democrats and 83 percent of independent voters also said they supported a path to citizenship for immigrants living illegally in the U.S.
“They’re already here,” said Dannette Tucker, a 37-year-old independent voter from San Jose, California. “I know they can go through a lot of hardship in order to get here, and I think if anyone is willing to go through that much trouble we should let them have some kind of path to get the rest of the way.”
Opinion is far more divided on the question of sanctuary cities, which restrict their local law enforcement agencies from helping federal authorities enforce immigration laws.
Half of those surveyed said sanctuary cities were needed. Forty-three percent said “undocumented immigrants should be deported, so there is no reason to have sanctuary cities.” The rest were unsure.
The responses fell sharply on party lines, with Democrats overwhelmingly in support of sanctuary cities and Republicans opposed. Trump signed an order last month denying federal funding to sanctuary cities, a move backed by 73 percent of Republicans polled.
Sanctuary cities are “just as bad as harboring criminals” said South Carolina Trump supporter Harwell.
But 73 percent of Democrats and 54 percent of independent voters said the federal government should not cut funds to cities that provided sanctuary to immigrants who are here illegally.
“It’s about being a decent human being, and I think cutting off funds is an inappropriate tactic,” said Melissa Sevier, 48, a registered Democrat from Arlington, Virginia. “It’s just bullying cities, and most of those cities are cities that did not vote for Trump and his cronies.”
Lindsay Wise contributed to this article.
How the survey was conducted
This survey of 1,073 adults was conducted Feb. 15-19 by The Marist Poll, sponsored and funded in partnership with McClatchy. People 18 years and older residing in the contiguous United States were contacted on landline or mobile numbers and interviewed in English by telephone using live interviewers. Landline telephone numbers were randomly selected based on a list of telephone exchanges from throughout the nation from ASDE Survey Sampler Inc. The exchanges were selected to ensure that each region was represented in proportion to its population. Respondents in the household were randomly selected by first asking for the youngest male. This landline sample was combined with respondents reached through random dialing of cellphone numbers from Survey Sampling International. After the interviews were completed, the two samples were combined and balanced to reflect the 2013 American Community Survey one-year estimates for age, gender, income, race and region. Results are statistically significant within ±3.0 percentage points. There are 865 registered voters. The results for this subset are statistically significant within ±3.3 percentage points. The error margin was not adjusted for sample weights and increases for cross-tabulations.