World

2 courts have overturned his conviction. So why is this Guantanamo prisoner in solitary?

Ali Hamza al Bahlul was sketched during his appearance before a military commission at Guantanamo Aug. 26, 2004 but the artist was prohibited from showing his face in detail. Bahlul was convicted, but civilian appeals courts twice held that he could not stand trial before a military commission for the charges that were leveled against him. Still, he remains the only prisoner at Guantanamo held in the section of the prison camp reserved for convicts.
Ali Hamza al Bahlul was sketched during his appearance before a military commission at Guantanamo Aug. 26, 2004 but the artist was prohibited from showing his face in detail. Bahlul was convicted, but civilian appeals courts twice held that he could not stand trial before a military commission for the charges that were leveled against him. Still, he remains the only prisoner at Guantanamo held in the section of the prison camp reserved for convicts. KRT

A month after a federal court set aside a 2008 tribunal’s conviction of Guantánamo’s lone convicted war criminal, the captive remains isolated as a convict in a maximum-security lockup.

Army Col. David Heath, who runs the guard force, said in an interview last week that, absent a specific order to change the status of Ali Hamza al Bahlul, the 40-something Yemeni who for a time functioned as Osama bin Laden’s Public Affairs Officer, remains a convict. Bahlul was convicted of making al-Qaida recruiting videos.

Guantánamo’s other 115 captives are considered “detainees,” and kept in a variety of statuses and five different types of lockups – including the six former CIA captives who await death-penalty trials by military commission and two who have provisionally pleaded guilty but not been sentenced.

A nine-officer military jury convicted Bahlul in 2008 of conspiring with al Qaida, solicitation and providing material support for terror and sentenced him to life in prison after a four-day, no-contest trial.

If he reverted to detainee status, given his compliancy level, he would be entitled to communal” living privileges.

Army Col. David Heath

Bahlul had his U.S. military attorney mount no defense but at one point declared he had aspired to become the 20th hijacker in the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks, something not alleged by the prosecution. At sentencing, he waved paper airplanes and boats he had fashioned, Origami style, to demonstrate his contempt of the proceedings that included a screening of his recruiting video that used a crude dramatization of the 2000 USS Cole bombing.

Civilian courts vacated those convictions in two sets of rulings that found those charges, as prosecuted, did not constitute war crimes. A federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., struck down his last conviction, on conspiracy, June12. The Justice Department has not disclosed whether it will appeal that ruling.

Civilian courts ruled the charges for which he was convicted did not constitute war crimes that could be tried by a military commission.

Bahlul, who is considered a compliant convict, remains the lone captive on the so-called Convicts Corridor of the maximum-security Camp 5 prison, said Heath, because the colonel has received no specific order from his military chain-of-command to move him. If so ordered, Heath said, he would then consult with the captive to see whether he was interested in joining other medium-security, cooperative captives in a communal cellblock.

“If he reverted to detainee status,” the colonel said, “given his compliancy level, he would be entitled to communal.”

On Sunday, Bahlul’s Pentagon appeals attorney, Michel Paradis, declined comment on the situation pending instructions from his client.

Bahlul has had no neighboring prisoner to converse with for nearly 20 months.

An undisclosed number of other compliant captives voluntarily live in solitary cells, military commanders say – rather than join the majority living in groups of a dozen or more who pray, eat, watch TV and play some sports together with the exception of two hours of daily lock-down in individual cell situations.

Bahlul got to Guantánamo Jan.11, 2002, meaning he has spent nearly half his time here as a convict, segregated behind a steel door with a slit through which guards pass books and meals. He has had no neighboring prisoner to converse or pray with through the walls for nearly 20 months.

Canadian convict Omar Khadr was repatriated in September 2012, and the U.S. sent home a Sudanese convict in December 2013, leaving Bahlul alone on the cellblock.

Only five of the 780 or more war-on-terror captives held here since 2002 were convicted and sentenced as war criminals. There are two men among the remaining 116 captives who have pleaded guilty to war crimes, but they have not been sentenced and so are not considered “convicts.”

If he is moved off of Convict’s Corridor, Bahlul would become the first former war criminal returned to the general detainee population. Other Guantánamo convicts whose convictions were overturned were already free in their home countries — Australia, Sudan, Yemen – when the United States declared them unwar criminals.

Follow @CarolRosenberg on Twitter

  Comments