Latest News

Racial undertones complicate handover of whip

WASHINGTON—It was supposed to have been a simple ceremony symbolizing a new bipartisan spirit in Washington:

The outgoing House majority whip, Republican Rep. Roy Blunt of Missouri, was to hand his successor, Democratic Rep. James Clyburn of South Carolina, an actual whip that had been on display in Blunt's leadership office at the U.S. Capitol.

But racial overtones apparently undermined the plan.

As camera flashes popped and video recorders whirled Thursday, Clyburn, a 66-year-old African-American from the South, did not receive the whip from Blunt, a 56-year-old white man from a border state.

Instead, Clyburn was given the whip by former Rep. William Gray of Philadelphia, who in 1989 became the first black House majority whip.

Blunt's spokeswoman, Jessica Boulanger, said it was her understanding that Gray wanted to give Clyburn a whip as a gift, "but you'd have to check with Mr. Clyburn's office." A Dec. 22 press release from Clyburn's office said Blunt would be presenting the whip to Clyburn. Clyburn, now the second African-American to hold the House's No. 3 post, declined repeated requests Thursday to explain why the ceremony was changed.

Ronald Walters, a black political science professor at the University of Maryland, said he had little doubt that racial sensitivity prompted the decision to have Clyburn receive the whip from a fellow African-American instead of from a white man.

"What it tells us is that race is still a very salient and touchy and dangerous issue to politicians," Walters said.

Recalling the criticism of former Sen. George Allen for having displayed a noose in his former law offices, Walters said the whip also remains a potent symbol for blacks.

"These symbols are still very raw," Walters said. "They drudge up memories of the way they were used to punish and brutalize black humanity."

Cole Blease Graham, a white political science professor at the University of South Carolina, said that in changing the ceremony, Clyburn missed an opportunity to highlight positive change in the country, and especially in the South.

"It's as if the various players are trapped in appearing politically correct, but missing the reality of the ceremony," Graham said. "Here is a person (Clyburn) who within his lifetime would have struggled to even register to vote. The fact that he's been able to achieve what he has is really one of the positive stories in American politics."

Maryland's Walters, though, said it was smart for Clyburn and Blunt to have changed the ceremony.

"They were attempting to restore some of the dignity of the moment," Walters said. "To me, it makes a lot of sense. What they tried to do was neutralize the racial component of this issue."

Walters and Graham noted that South Carolina has been at the center of none-too-distant racial controversies.

Sen. Trent Lott resigned as Senate majority leader in December 2002 after a public uproar over his laudatory comments about Strom Thurmond at the late senator's 100th birthday party. Lott said the country might have been better off if Thurmond had been elected president in 1948 when he ran as a segregationist from South Carolina.

The Confederate flag was removed from its perch above the state Capitol in Columbia in 2000 after years of debate. In a compromise, a smaller Confederate flag is displayed on the Capitol grounds near a monument to Confederate soldiers, and a new monument to African-Americans was built on the grounds.

The National Association for the Advancement of Colored People is still protesting the display of the smaller Confederate flag.


(David Goldstein of the McClatchy Washington Bureau contributed.)


(c) 2007, McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

Need to map

Related stories from McClatchy DC