Latest News

Pope influenced Latin America but region will challenge his successor

RIO DE JANEIRO, Brazil—Home to nearly half of the world's Roman Catholics, Latin America was a priority for Pope John Paul II and will surely prove a challenge for his successor.

John Paul II helped oust right-wing dictatorships in South America shortly after becoming pope in 1978. He helped broker peace between dictatorships in Chile and Argentina that were near war, then supported pro-democracy opponents of dictatorships across the region.

"He was a pope who fought for democratic liberties in Latin America. When he came to power there were many dictatorships still and he helped precipitate the re-democratization of Brazil" and most of the region, said Clodovis Boff, theologian and historian.

More recently, in 1998 John Paul II pushed Cuban dictator Fidel Castro to allow the church to resume a public role on the Communist island and to reopen a convent.

John Paul II also frowned on the Marxist-tinged liberation-theology movement that rocked the church in Latin America in the 1980's, when many younger priests backed leftist insurgencies in Central America to "free" the poor from rich ruling families.

The church initially sided with the Marxist Sandinista movement in Nicaragua. But John Paul II stood with President Ronald Reagan in his Cold War bid to keep socialist governments from gaining power in Central America. John Paul II was jeered in Nicaragua when he said the church stood with the poor but believed Marxism was at odds with freedom.

"He said priests were becoming politicians, but he was a politician of note," said Rodrigo Paez Montealban, a sociologist at the National Autonomous University in Mexico City.

The pope displayed his political skills perhaps best in Mexico, the second most-populous Catholic nation. His first papal trip was to the Dominican Republic and Mexico. The church had been on the defensive since the anti-clerical Mexican revolution of 1910-1917. But after repeated papal visits, then-President Carlos Salinas de Gortari in 1992 renewed the church's legal standing in Mexico.

"This was a normalization that totally changed the church-state relationship," said Paez Montealban.

Throughout Latin America, many separated respect for John Paul II from aversion to his rigid message against birth control. Studies show that many Mexican and Brazilian women practice birth control in defiance of church teachings.

In sensual Brazil, the world's most populous Catholic nation, church teachings on sexuality have been largely ignored and some priests actively promote condom use.

John Paul II was the first pope to visit Brazil; he did so four times.

His successor will face steep challenges there. Brazil has the largest number of African descendants outside Africa, and many are turning to a growing African-mysticism movement.

The Catholic Church is losing ground even faster to a growing Christian evangelical movement that has won many congressional seats and is making itself felt across Brazilian culture.

The pontiff's successor will face a full plate across Latin America. In Bolivia and Ecuador, indigenous leaders are seizing power and view the church as complicit in their long history of oppression. In a replay of the 1970's, many voters disillusioned that democracy has not brought higher living standards are voting for leftist governments.

Theologian Boff said the next pope must understand, as John Paul II did, that Latin America is crucial to the worldwide church.

"The epicenter of the church is in the Third World. It came down to the tropics," said Boff. Of John Paul II's legacy, he said: "He was a great geo-politician."


(c) 2005, Knight Ridder/Tribune Information Services.

Need to map