Can anyone stop Donald Trump? Or at least get tough with the Republican front-runner?
Wednesday’s Republican debate is a crucial test for the party’s would-be presidents, who have spent the summer largely in the shadow of the outspoken, often polarizing real estate mogul.
Ben Carson, John Kasich and Carly Fiorina have inched out of the pack in recent weeks, but can they demonstrate the gravitas to become serious players? Can Jeb Bush, Rand Paul, Scott Walker and other big names mired in political quicksand climb out? How risky will it be to confront Trump?
A lot of answers are likely as 11 Republicans gather Wednesday at 8 p.m. EDT at the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library for the campaign’s second debate. The others will participate in an earlier debate from 6-7:45 p.m.
Here’s what the main event’s contenders need to do to stand out:
Tier One: The front-runner
Can he expand his support? Trump has won the backing support from a solid 30 percent of Republicans in most polls, but huge blocs of other voters view him unfavorably. That’s politically toxic, and Trump needs to show he can expand his constituency. Watch whether he seems more intent on being presidential or being entertaining. Is he more eager to offer policy details or tweetable sound bites?
Tier Two: Moving up
Can he come off as presidential? He got good notices from conservatives after the first debate. They appreciated the retired neurosurgeon’s quiet style, deeply felt faith and ability to talk issues in some depth. Carson now needs to show command of the intricacies of national security and economic issues. He also must show that while he has strong, often controversial views on social issues, he’s tolerant and understanding of others.
18% Ben Carson’s showing in the Monmouth University poll Aug. 31-Sept. 2, up 13 points from the pre-August debate poll.
Will Republicans welcome his center-right views? The governor of Ohio, one of the last Republicans to enter the race, quickly surged into second place in New Hampshire polls. Many voters appreciated his down-to-earth style and willingness to challenge conservative orthodoxy. Rivals will challenge him on those views, notably his decision to support Medicaid expansion under the Affordable Care Act.
Can she continue to shine on national security? The former business executive’s discussion of foreign policy at the August second-tier debate won her strong notices. This time she’s in center court, fresh from being insulted by Trump for her appearance. Will she take him on? Will she stand out?
Tier Three: Stuck
Can he energize his campaign? The former Florida governor was supposed to be most viable alternative to Trump, thanks to his family’s political network and his ability to raise big money. He retains strong potential, but so far he has failed to break out of the pack. He needs to forget Trump, show what he stands for, and rally voters looking for a substantive alternative.
6% Jeb Bush’s support among Iowa Republicans in latest NBC-Marist poll, a distant third behind Trump and Carson.
How does he separate himself from Trump? No one has been hurt as much as the senator from Texas by Trump’s rise. Cruz has fashioned himself as the sharp-tongued, anti-Washington candidate, but so has Trump. Cruz has been careful not to criticize the front-runner, and confronting him would risk alienating his followers. But how does Cruz distinguish himself?
Is his methodical campaign too patient? Rubio has quietly, steadily built his campaign, figuring that as voters get more serious early next year, they’ll see what a smart, reasonable, telegenic candidate he is. His mission is similar to Bush’s – break away from the Trump orbit and explain why he should be president.
Tier Four: Teetering
Where is he? Paul’s father rallied a devoted libertarian constituency when he ran in 2012, but his son seems to be doing little with it. Or with anything else. Paul got aggressive in the August debate, but it didn’t get him far. He badly needs to stand out this time, perhaps by championing what he calls more realistic, constitutionally based policies governing foreign affairs.
Can he get noticed? Hard to think the big, blustery governor of New Jersey has been invisible, but he seemed all but forgotten in the last debate. The format is not his friend, since Christie’s plainspoken tough-guy persona can’t break through when it’s only visible for minutes at a time.
There was one point where I went 20 questions in a row without being asked a question, and that’s hard. Chris Christie discussing the August debate with “Tonight Show” host Jimmy Fallon
Can he expand his constituency? The former governor of Arkansas has assiduously courted social conservatives, appearing last week with Kentucky court clerk Kim Davis, jailed after she refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. Can Huckabee show more mainstream appeal?
Can he demonstrate some depth? Walker’s had a rough summer. His Iowa poll lead not only evaporated, but he fell to 10th place in last week’s Quinnipiac poll. He had three different positions on birthright citizenship in a single week last month. The governor of Wisconsin needs to establish himself as a thoughtful would-be commander in chief.
CORRECTION: An earlier version of this story had incorrect timing for Huckabee’s meeting with Kentucky court clerk Kim Davis.