• Posted on Monday, March 10, 2008
  • email
  • |
  • print
  • |
  • rss

tool name

close
tool goes here

Red state sweetheart

logout | member center

Long ago, in the days when disco ruled the earth, Esquire magazine awarded one of its Dubious Achievement Awards to a most resilient Russian woman. A dozen times she had been declared dead, if I remember it right, and a dozen times doctors brought her back to life. The headline was unforgettable. "Hit her with a stick."

That pretty well sums up the general mood of liberal bloggers in the wake of Sen. Hillary Clinton's March 4 return from death after victories in Ohio and Rhode Island: Just hit her with a stick.

They charge, as Oliver Willis puts it, that "the Clinton campaign has decided that it will lay waste to the Democratic party if she cannot get the nomination." And Exhibit #1 in that indictment is Clinton's March 6 statement that only she and Sen. John McCain "can cross the commander-in-chief threshold."

The statement precipitated an instant hail of adjectives: "repugnant"; "fratricidal in a way that's not excusable... disgraceful"; "inexcusable"; "unforgivably self-destructive"; "appalling, totally beyond the pale... a special kind of stupid." "To produce a clip that the McCain campaign could run unedited every single day of a campaign against Obama?" James Fallows writes at TheAtlantic. "That is something special."

One of the rules of politics, writes former Sen. Gary Hart, who knows them from his own rough experience as a presidential candidate, is not to give the opposing party ammunition to lob at your party's eventual nominee.

"By saying that only she and John McCain are qualified to lead the country, particularly in times of crisis, Hillary Clinton has broken that rule, severely damaged the Democratic candidate who may well be the party's nominee, and, perhaps most ominously, revealed the unlimited lengths to which she will go to achieve power. She has essentially said that the Democratic party deserves to lose unless it nominates her."

In the eyes of many liberal bloggers, Clinton is guilty not just of tearing down Sen. Barack Obama, the frontrunner for the nomination, but of puffing up her own foreign credentials.

"The obvious downside to making this case is the inconvenient fact that she actually doesn't have extensive foreign policy experience," hilzoy writes at Obsidian Wings. "She must, therefore, be gambling that people won't notice this." In a series of posts, hilzoy looks at the record and recent newspaper reports and she finds the record doesn't support Clinton's boasts.

Josh Marshall at Talking Points Memo similarly finds Clinton's claims "a joke." With no executive experience and only seven years in the Senate, "she's pushing a metric by which she's little distinguishable from Barack Obama. I'm honestly surprised she's not drawing chuckles on this one." Steve Benen at The Carpetbagger Report agrees. "Clinton simply isn’t a Joe Biden-like candidate. Why pretend that she is?"

The real dagger thrust comes, though, from that sleeping little blond girl that Clinton vows to protect in her much-discussed (and much parodied) 3 a.m. telephone ad. It turns out the girl has somehow managed to grow up safely even with George Bush answering the telephone and is taking part in her first presidential election––as a precinct captain for Obama.

The optimists in the liberal blogosphere believe that the extended presidential contest is good for the Democratic party. It is "creating vast numbers of new Democrats, improving our general election standing, creating new swing states, turning existing swing states blue, allowing small donors to take over direct funding the Democratic Party in the Presidential election, and swamping Republicans in fundraising," Chris Bowers writes at OpenLeft. "This process is working," TeddySanFran crows at Firedoglake, "and Americans are listening."

And none more happily these days than conservative bloggers. For once, they don't want to hit Hillary with a stick; they want her to keep talking. Scott Johnson at Powerline links to the "inspired" John McCain remix of Hillary's 3 a.m. phone ad. And Mark Kilmer, listening to Clinton praise McCain's readiness, urges her on: "Hillary's yap, when she opens it, can be a fine thing."

Hillary Clinton, the darling of Rush Limbaugh and Redstate.com. Can this year get any more strange?

WELCOME TO ALT.CAMPAIGN

A poet? A screenplay with fictional endings? Pop culture?

What's all that doing alongside the REAL campaign coverage on a news site?

Well, it's amplifying, we hope. Illuminating. Invigorating.

The feature called "alt.campaign" is an alternative look at the presidential campaign. A world where YouTube and Swift Boats are crowding Tim Russert and George Will deserves some new points of view. When one of the top stories from the real campaign is about an Obama Girl who doesn't have a thing to do with the Obama campaign, you might as well ask a screenwriter to spin out some alternative endings now and then.

We're asking a handful of high-quality observers to make some non-traditional observations for you as this campaign unfolds. Your ideas, reactions, suggestions and opinions are solicited. Help Joe find an angle that needs coverage in our campaign screenplay. Whisper campaign secrets in Amy's always-eager ear. Send us your own video coverage of campaign events, or your own commentary about the unfolding pageant of democracy.

And welcome to alt.campaign.

ABOUT JESSICA HAGY

Jessica Hagy is a cartoonist and writer living in the swinging state of Ohio. At indexed.blogspot.com, she posts charts, graphs, and Venn diagrams drawn on index cards that the make fun of some subjects and sense of others. Her first book will be relased by Penguin's Viking Studio in February. E-mail: jhagy@yahoo.com

ABOUT JOE ACTON

Joe Acton was born and raised in Alaska with a typical upbringing: dodging earthquakes, fishing commercially, flying airplanes, and spending most winters trying to figure how to get the hell out (what, like on "Career Day" they couldn't have mentioned the other 48 states?). Law school finally got him out and the easy weather in Seattle kept him out. Now Zaydoe Films keeps him busy as a writer and director. E-mail: jacton@mcclatchydc.com

ABOUT MARK PAUL

Mark Paul, Senior Scholar at the New America Foundation, caught the political bug early — his first summer job at 15 was with the campaign of a Republican U.S. Senate candidate in Wisconsin — and he has stayed hooked through his career as a journalist, historian, and policy wonk. Formerly a deputy editorial page editor and columnist for the Sacramento Bee, he has served as Deputy Treasurer of the State of California and policy director for the 2006 gubernatorial campaign of Phil Angelides, a Democrat. He lives and writes in Sacramento, Calif. E-mail: mpaul@mcclatchydc.com

ABOUT AMY Z. QUINN

Amy Z. Quinn started out as a "real" journalist, working as an award-winning reporter, editorial writer and columnist for the Asbury Park Press and the Philadelphia Inquirer, before realizing that life as a stay-at-home mom offered better material for about the same pay. Since 2004, she's blogged at her own site, Citizen Mom, and also writes and edits at Phawker.com. She writes from her home in the Philadelphia suburbs.

ABOUT RIVES

Rives is part poet, part storyteller, and all maverick. He favors wordplay, romance, jokes you can't remember, and anecdotes that don't suck. He has appeared on the last four seasons of "HBO's Def Poetry Jam," and he was the 2004 National Poetry Slam champion. Originally trained as a "paper engineer," Rives has designed and written several pop-up books for children. Visit his Web site at Shopliftwindchimes.com.