Mexico steps back from made-for-TV arrests, ‘perp walks’

McClatchy NewspapersJanuary 25, 2013 


Gulf Cartel members arrested and on display in 2007.


— Mexican authorities on Friday pledged major changes in the way criminal suspects are treated, citing an urgent need to improve a judiciary that’s suffering from rock-bottom conviction rates and wounded by public anger at the lack of a rule of law.

Starting immediately, Mexico’s Federal Police and military personnel will read a series of legal rights to suspects – including rights to know the charges against them, obtain free legal counsel and remain silent – from printed cards they carry with them.

The announcement by Undersecretary Eduardo Sanchez of the Interior Secretariat was another sign that President Enrique Pena Nieto is racing to distance himself from practices under the previous government, which left power Dec. 1.

Earlier this week, Sanchez told the quasi-official Notimex news agency that police no longer would put alleged gangsters on display in “perp walks” before banks of television cameras.

Nor would authorities post “most wanted” lists, allow news media to air raids in action or refer to gangsters by aliases, acts that critics said glorified the underworld.

"It is not acceptable, nor will it ever be under this government, that authorities conduct themselves in arbitrary ways that hurt society (or) lead to impunity and injustice,” Sanchez told a news conference. He added that law enforcement officials no longer would treat criminals in a way “for young people in our country to feel that it is attractive, or that criminal activities are a good way to develop socially.”

Faith in Mexico’s justice system hit a low point this week. The Supreme Court ruled in a 3-2 vote Wednesday to release a Frenchwoman accused of belonging to a kidnapping gang from her 60-year jail term.

As relatives of kidnapping victims wept along the roadside outside the prison, the woman, Florence Cassez, was whisked to the international airport to board a flight to France, where she was greeted as a returning survivor of a corrupt justice system.

French President Francois Hollande welcomed Cassez and her family Friday evening at the Elysee Palace in Paris.

Her release sparked anger and indignation in Mexico, where leftist lawmakers demanded that Genaro Garcia Luna, who was the head of public security under former President Felipe Calderon, be brought to a hearing on his conduct in the case.

Cassez was freed partly because Garcia Luna had staged her “capture” in 2005 for television reporters a day after her arrest, pretending it was a real commando raid.

Prosecutors said that Cassez, 38, took part in at least three kidnappings, including one of a minor, with the gang Los Zodiacos. She claimed that she knew nothing of the activities of her onetime boyfriend, allegedly a member of Los Zodiacos.

Marieclaire Acosta Urquidi, the project director in Mexico for Freedom House, a Washington-based advocacy group for political and civil liberties worldwide, hailed Friday’s Interior Secretariat announcement.

“It is an absolute necessity,” she said, “and the excesses of the past six years are eloquent proof of that. We have more victims than ever and an enormous number of disappeared” persons.

“The fabrication of ‘guilty’ parties, the lies, the twisting of the law, the use of torture, use of lethal force without adequate protocols, all of these factors do not generate confidence or help resolve security problems,” she said.

Before Calderon left office, he repeatedly boasted that his government had killed or captured 25 of the 37 most wanted drug lords in Mexico.

But his Attorney General’s Office acknowledged in a report five months ago that only 31 percent of the thousands of Mexicans who were arrested on drug charges from 2006 to 2011 were convicted.

Eight out of 10 murders in Mexico go unpunished, according to a study last year by Guillermo Zepeda, a rule-of-law expert at the Western Institute of Technology and Higher Education, a Jesuit-run university in Guadalajara.

Email:; Twitter: @timjohnson4

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service