Romney narrowly edges Santorum in hotly contested Ohio

McClatchy NewspapersMarch 6, 2012 

WASHINGTON — Mitt Romney beat Rick Santorum by 1 percent in Ohio's critical Republican primary race Tuesday, as the two GOP presidential candidates battled into the wee hours in the hardest-fought contest of Super Tuesday.

Romney, who also won five other states, had 38 percent of the Ohio vote to Santorum's 37 percent with 96 percent of votes counted.

Romney’s Ohio victory firmly established the former Massachusetts governor as the candidate to beat for the 2012 GOP nomination. But Santorum, the former U. S. senator from Pennsylvania, made it clear that he has significant support.

On the biggest day of the 2012 primary and caucus season, Santorum won Tennessee, Oklahoma and North Dakota. In addition to Ohio, Romney won Virginia, Vermont, Massachusetts, Alaska and Idaho.

Newt Gingrich, the former speaker of the House of Representatives, won his former home state of Georgia. Alaska also held caucuses Tuesday, and Texas Rep. Ron Paul was making a strong effort there.

Romney was the clear winner in the delegate race, as he piled up delegates to this summer's Republican National Convention and crept closer to the 1,144 delegates needed to nominate. 419 delegates were at stake Tuesday.

The biggest prize was Ohio. The state matters because it's a big state mixture of urban and rural, blue collar and high tech. And no Republican has ever won the presidency without winning the state.

A Romney win, one week after he triumphed in neighboring Michigan, his native state, would be an important sign that he has broad appeal in crucial states. But a Santorum victory, after his close second-place showing in Michigan, would raise fresh doubts about Romney's viability.

Gingrich was hoping the Georgia victory would revitalize his almost-moribund campaign. Its 76 delegates are the day's single-biggest state total.

Santorum and Gingrich started the day far behind in delegates and remained well behind Romney. But they hoped to demonstrate strength in the South, where Romney has proven less popular.

Romney needed more than numbers Tuesday — he needed to demonstrate strong, broad appeal to a Republican constituency that has had qualms about his commitment to conservatism.

Romney governed Massachusetts as a center-right executive, and it's common on the campaign trail to find GOP voters still upset that he signed into law a near-universal health care requirement in his state.

Those same voters, though, are eager to see President Barack Obama defeated and often say Romney is the most electable challenger.

Ohio was the big test.

As results showing wins in several states rolled in, Santorum addressed Ohio supporters Tuesday night.

"We have won in the West, the Midwest and the South," he said, "and we are ready to win across the country."

Romney addressed supporters in Boston, and drew sharp contrasts with President Barack Obama. He also talked briefly about his candidacy.

He addressed supporters in Boston before Ohio's results were in.

"I’ve listened and I’ve learned. I hope I’m a better candidate for it. And I will be forever grateful for this greatest of experiences," he said.

He reminded backers he's still ahead in the delegate count, reminding them, "Tonight, we are counting up the delegates for the convention — and counting down the days until November."

Exit polls from Ohio and Tennessee found voters there overwhelmingly gave Romney the edge as the candidate most likely to beat Obama.

Romney's business experience helped him in Ohio as well as Georgia and Tennessee, as voters preferred business to government experience by a 2-to-1 margin. But they were also conservative — evangelical Christians were about two-thirds of the Georgia electorate, three-fourths of Tennessee voters and nearly half of Ohio’s.

Paul traveled to Idaho and North Dakota on Tuesday. He attracted about 900 people in Nampa, Idaho, where he outlined his "Path to Restore America," including $1 trillion in federal spending cuts his first year in office.

Gingrich, campaigning in Duluth, Ga., outside Atlanta, told supporters that he was the only candidate capable of making bold changes in Washington. "The truth is that I have opponents who are — in a normal period — adequate," he said, "but they don't have anything like the scale of change" he would implement.

MORE FROM MCCLATCHY

Follow David Lightman on Twitter: @LightmanDavid

For more McClatchy politics coverage visit Planet Washington

Gingrich pursues Southern strategy to break back into 2-man race

Santorum's appeal? He resonates with tea party activists

Super Tuesday - 10 states, coast to coast, and it's all about delegates

Ohio economy has highs, lows as Super Tuesday approaches

McClatchy Newspapers 2012

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service