Get tough on Iran, GOP candidates agree, but how tough?

McClatchy NewspapersNovember 12, 2011 

SPARTANBURG, S.C. — Republicans lambasted President Barack Obama Saturday night as weak and misguided on the world stage, but differed in a debate over how they would rein in Iran's reported effort to develop nuclear weapons.

They all said that Obama has failed to stop Iran from working to develop a nuclear weapon, but their prescriptions for what to do differently ranged from increasing sanctions to assassinating Iranian scientists to going to war.

Former Gov. Mitt Romney of Massachusetts said he would push "crippling" sanctions first, then work with Iranian dissidents to help them overthrow the government. If neither worked, he said, "then of course you take military action."

Former House Speaker Newt Gingrich said he'd order "maximum covert operations...including taking out their scientists...all of it covertly, all of it deniable." He too said he would not rule out military strikes. "You have to take whatever steps are necessary," he added.

Businessman Herman Cain of Georgia said he'd assist the opposition movement in Iran to force "regime change." He said he would deploy U.S. warships near Iran as a show of force, but that, "I would not entertain military options."

Rep. Ron Paul of Texas said flatly that he would not go to war to stop Iran - and that no president should have the power to order military action without a declaration from Congress.

"I'm afraid what's going on right now is similar to the war propaganda that went on against Iraq," Paul said.

Gov. Rick Perry of Texas said he'd order sanctions immediately on the Iranian central bank "and shut down the country's economy."

Former Sen. Rick Santorum said the U.S. should work with Israel to help it "take out" the Iranian nuclear facilities as it did once each in Iraq and Syria.

The International Atomic Energy Agency this week reported that Iran is apparently trying to make a nuclear weapon. Iran called the report a lie, but Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton said the United States is still waiting for an official response.

On Afghanistan, Romney blasted Obama for bringing "surge" troops home by next September, calling it a political decision to begin ending the war before the 2012 elections. Perry and Rep. Michele Bachmann of Minnesota made similar points.

Huntsman differed.

"I say it's time to come home," he said, since the U.S. has achieved its objectives and has bigger priorities elsewhere. "This nation's future is not Afghanistan."

Asked about the killing of radical Muslim cleric Anwar al Awlaki, a U.S. citizen in Yemen, most of the candidates said the president has the power to order the deaths of citizens if they're deemed to be terrorists. Paul disagreed.

The 90-minute faceoff was televised nationally on CBS, though under an unusual arrangement that cut it off after one hour in most American homes. CBS affiliates in South Carolina and many on the West Coast showed the entire debate, but those in the rest of the country ended coverage at the one hour mark to allow broadcast of the highly rated entertainment program NCIS.

The debate came as Republican voters threaten to shake up the race again. A new McClatchy-Marist poll shows Romney retaking the lead nationally, Gingrich surging into second place, and Cain dropping back to third.

Gingrich, invited to challenge Romney face to face as he has on the campaign trail, refused.

"No," he said flatly when asked if wanted to explain his comments that Romney could manage Washington, but could not change it profoundly, as Gingrich said he could.

"I brought it up yesterday because it was a national radio show," he said, adding that the debate was a place to draw contrasts with Obama, not one another.

Perry got a shot at redemption when moderator Scott Pelley of CBS asked about Perry's proposal to eliminate the federal Department of Energy. Perry could not remember in a Wednesday night debate that the U.S. Energy Department was one of three he's proposed closing.

"I'm glad you remembered it," Perry said, drawing laughter from the audience.

"I had some time to think about it," Pelley said.

"Me too," a smiling Perry said.

(Thomma reported from Spartanburg, S.C., Lightman from Washington, D.C.)

ON THE WEB:

McClatchy-Marist poll

IAEA Iran report

For more McClatchy politics coverage visit Planet Washington

More from McClatchy:

Poll: Romney leads, Gingrich surges, Cain sinks

Who's the next hot GOP candidate? Maybe it's Gingrich

Perry pokes fun at his brain freeze, but his campaign is wounded

Follow Steven Thomma on Twitter

McClatchy Newspapers 2011

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service