Will Perry's halting debate style produce a faltering campaign?

McClatchy NewspapersSeptember 25, 2011 

ORLANDO, Fla. — Rick Perry's charge toward the Republican presidential nomination has stalled.

In a bruising turn of events, the Texas governor turned in a weak performance in a nationally televised debate in Florida Thursday, raised questions about how ready he is for the rigors of a tough campaign and how much Republicans really know about the man, and then by a wide margin lost a straw poll of Florida Republicans he had tried hard to win.

At the same time, chief rival Mitt Romney scored with a sharp performance in the debate, his third in a row. And others shone in the eyes of Republican voters as well, including Atlanta business executive Herman Cain, who delivered a sharp debate performance, then won the Florida straw poll with more than twice as many votes as Perry.

Taken together, the results heading out of Florida signal that the party is far from ready to coalesce behind Perry, and that his lead in the contest is in jeopardy.

"Perry created some doubt about himself," said Susan MacManus, a political scientist at the University of South Florida who attended the three-day gathering of more than 3,000 conservative activists in Orlando.

"This is a world of people used to good speakers with clear views," she said. "They worry now about his ability to stand beside President Obama in a debate."

In the aftermath of the debate, it was all but impossible to find anyone at the "Presidency 5" weekend who thought Perry did well. The criticisms included his style — uniformly described as halting and unsure — and the substance, particularly his defense of in-state college tuition breaks for children of illegal immigrants not available to citizens from other states.

"Perry looked uncomfortable. He got caught up on a couple of the questions. He was inconsistent," said Meg Shannon, a retired lawyer from Palm Beach Gardens, Fla., who attended the debate.

"I was leaning toward Mitt, but I wanted to hear the candidates," she said. "Mitt did very well."

Harold Armstrong, a pastor from St. Cloud, Fla., who attended the debate and a Conservative Political Action Conference on Friday, also came away unimpressed by Perry.

"I did not think Perry did well. He seemed a little tentative," Armstrong said.

He said that Romney "came across looking presidential" and that his own favorite, Newt Gingrich, scored by offering what he thought were the best answers. "He gives thoughtful replies, not canned responses," Armstrong said.

Jean Morris, a retired teacher from St. Cloud, walked away still leaning toward Perry. But she, too, acknowledged that he didn't do very well.

On the question of in-state tuition for illegal immigrants, for example, she said he fumbled by failing to stress that it also requires those students to promise to seek permanent resident status as a condition for the tuition break. "It disappointed me that he didn't mention that," she said.

Perry's performance underscored how fast he surged to the lead when he jumped into the race just six weeks ago, how untested he is, and how unscrutinized his record is beyond his boast of creating jobs.

Despite his 10 years as governor, Perry had only faced rivals in a debate four times before he starting running for president. He's now debated three times on that stage.

Some analysts said he tires, and finishes poorly.

Perry's also facing tough scrutiny over the less advertised parts of his record, such as the support for in-state tuition and opposition to a fence along the U.S.-Mexico border, both touchy subjects for conservatives.

William Gheen, president of the Americans for Legal Immigration Political Action Committee, a North Carolina group, said that 81 percent of Americans oppose in-state tuition breaks for the children of illegal immigrants. "Rick Perry is finished," he said.

From the podium Thursday, Perry brushed aside anyone who opposes the tuition breaks as heartless. That set up Santorum to score by noting that conservatives don't want to deny the students access to college, as Perry suggested, just the prudential tuition denied to citizens from other states.

"Perry made a fundamental mistake when he said you have no heart. That was the moment when Perry people said, 'We can't take this, it's too much,'" said Luntz, who conducted a focus group for Fox News of Florida Republicans watching the debate.

Another stumble came when Perry was asked why he hasn't produced a detailed plan to create jobs, as other candidates have done. He said only that he'll produce one later.

"They thought he was ill prepared," Luntz said. "They think at this point you should have a plan. He was caught flatfooted."

Ultimately, Perry still has strengths in the still-developing campaign for the 2012 Republican nomination. He has a record of job growth in his home state to brag about. He has a generally conservative record. And he's got a warm style of campaigning one on one matched by charisma.

What he doesn't have, as this week showed, is an ability to face rivals and win in televised debates, one key element of the coming campaign for the nomination and then against Barack Obama.

"He has a presence," said Luntz. "They see it. They feel it. But he needs to acquire the ability to articulate to go along with that presence."

MORE FROM MCCLATCHY

In debate, Perry defends stance on immigration, border security

Is Newt really campaigning? His team says he's gearing up

Poll: Obama expected to lose but still tops any Republican one-on-one

For more McClatchy politics coverage visit Planet Washington

(email: sthomma(at)mcclatchydc.com)

McClatchy Newspapers 2011

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service