Mubarak allies make concessions in bid to quell protests

McClatchy NewspapersFebruary 5, 2011 

FILE - In this Sunday, July 1, 2007 file photo Gamal Mubarak, son of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, attends the funeral of Ashraf Marwan, wealthy businessman and controversial son-in-law of Egypt's late President Gamal Abdel Nasser, in Cairo, Egypt . State TV says the leadership of Egypt's ruling party, including party secretary-general Safwat el-Sharif and Gamal Mubarak the son of the president, resigned Saturday Feb. 5, 2011 in a new gesture to protesters. (AP Photo/Ben Curtis, File)


CAIRO — Senior officials resigned from Egypt's ruling National Democratic Party on Saturday in the latest government shake-up aimed at quelling the massive movement demanding President Hosni Mubarak's resignation.

The departures of Mubarak's son and onetime heir apparent, Gamal, along with several other party leaders came as regime officials opened talks with opposition leaders over the transition to a post-Mubarak era and took steps to restore normal life to a capital paralyzed by 12 straight days of protests.

With another massive anti-government rally called for Monday, the Egyptian government is struggling to strike a difficult balance: pacifying the protesters while allowing the Mubarak regime to manage a political transition that the Obama administration and other allies insist must begin now. U.S. officials are backing a transition plan led by Vice President Omar Suleiman, Mubarak's longtime confidant and spy chief, who met Saturday with some opposition leaders and intellectuals to discuss their demands.

Experts and protest organizers warned, however, that those opposition leaders didn't speak directly for the broad-based democracy movement — a leaderless grassroots collection that ranges from young liberals organized via Facebook to Islamists of the Muslim Brotherhood — and it was far from clear how many would be satisfied enough with the concessions to leave the streets. Demonstrators have stated repeatedly that nothing short of Mubarak's immediate resignation would end the protests.

Over the past week, Mubarak, who's ruled for nearly three decades, has said he'd step down after elections scheduled for this fall, that Gamal wouldn't replace him and that presidential term limits should be imposed. The regime also has slapped travel bans and asset freezes on leading political figures over charges of wrongdoing.

But Mubarak has staunchly refused to resign and hasn't addressed the protesters' other key demands, such as lifting a 30-year emergency law or dissolving a parliament almost completely filled with ruling party members.

The strategy has failed to peel off many protesters, who gathered in perhaps their largest numbers yet on Friday in downtown Cairo's Tahrir Square despite two days of deadly clashes with pro-Mubarak gangs.

Experts said that Mubarak was following an old tactic of regimes in times of duress: managing a transition to protect the status and privileges of their elites.

"The target of the regime's actions now is to draw a wedge between those who want to stay and protest and those willing to leave if some of their demands are met," said Shadi Hamid, research director at the Brookings Doha Center, a think tank in Qatar.

"The constant stream of reforms, changes and commitments are all meant to create the narrative that things are in fact going in a positive direction and there's no need for people to be in the streets anymore. But there hasn't been any real fundamental reform of the system yet."

A brief cheer went up from Tahrir Square, where a steady rain and tougher Egyptian army presence had thinned the crowd considerably, when news arrived of the ruling party reshuffle, which included the departure of general secretary Safwat El Sharif. He'll be replaced by Hossam Badrawy, a wealthy physician and reputed reformer, who broke ranks with the party over restrictions on presidential candidates.

A senior U.S. official said of Gamal Mubarak's resignation: "We view this as a positive step toward the political change that will be necessary, and look forward to additional steps." The official wasn't authorized to comment for the record.

Suleiman has insisted, however, that Mubarak won't resign before elections scheduled for this September. Officials also said that a White House proposal to have Mubarak cede decision-making powers to Suleiman during a transitional period would be unconstitutional.

"(Mubarak) clearly has no problem with being a former president. But he does have a problem with being a deposed president," an Arab official, requesting anonymity to speak frankly, said this week.

Several protesters objected to the White House's preference for Suleiman, the longtime head of the notorious Mukhabarat secret police, to lead the transition.

"This is a totally unacceptable idea," said Hossam Hamalawy, a prominent journalist and activist who's participated in the demonstrations. "(Suleiman) has always the No. 2 man in the regime. Nothing happens in the country without his and Mubarak's approval.

"He is very close to the Americans and to the Israelis...and it's out of the question that we will accept him as president or figurehead in the current regime, let alone pushing the transitional government."

But Egyptian officials continued argue that life was returning to normal despite some $3 billion in estimated losses due to the demonstrations. State media reported that Mubarak met with his economic team, and banks were set to reopen Sunday for the first time in more than a week.

"For every day that goes by, stability returns and we are more hopeful," Prime Minster Ahmed Shafiq said on state television.

The Egyptian army significantly increased its presence around Tahrir Square, carting off some burned vehicles and other detritus left by last week's clashes, and for several hours attempted to push tanks through a makeshift barricade near the Egyptian Museum, scene of the heaviest fighting. Protesters formed a human chain to protect the barricade, and soldiers finally said they wouldn't force them to leave.

Activists said the hard-core protesters would try to guard the hard-won square until Mubarak resigned and wouldn't be swayed by the recent concessions.

"Some of these demands are probably satisfying, but the problem do we guarantee this will happen," said Mohammed Waked, a protester and political activist.

"Once the protesters are out of Tahrir it will be a different type of negotiation, and they have no confidence in the regime to fulfill its promises. So that's why people are sticking very strongly to the symbolic claim of getting rid of Mubarak, because it's assured that it happens now."

(El Naggar is a special correspondent. Warren P. Strobel contributed to this report from Washington.)


Obama walks a delicate line with Egypt crisis

'Day of departure' ends with Mubarak still in power

Egypt's prime minister apologizes for violence in Cairo

A brief look at major players in Egypt's political crisis

Despite close contacts, U.S. in dark about Egypt military's views

Huge crowd demands Mubarak go in largest protest yet

Obama sends veteran diplomat to meet with Mubarak regime

McClatchy Newspapers 2010

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service