• Posted on Thursday, February 3, 2011
  • Bookmark and Share
  • email
  • |
  • print
  • |
  • rss

tool name

close
tool goes here

Commentary: Fast-track health care bill to Supreme Court

Stay Connected

Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Facebook Follow us on your iPhone
Follow us on your Android device Sign up for email newsletters RSS

Democrats and Republicans are at fierce odds over the health care bill, but they should agree with Florida Sen. Bill Nelson's call for the Supreme Court to decide whether the provision requiring purchase of health insurance is constitutional -- sooner than later.

Let's have a decision that counts. So far we have dueling rulings that don't settle the issue.

Federal judges in Michigan and Virginia have ruled that mandatory purchase -- which insurance companies say is necessary to bankroll other provisions of the health care act passed last March -- is constitutional.

Another federal judge in Virginia and one in Florida have ruled that mandatory purchase is unconstitutional -- and the Florida judge, Roger Vinson, found that his ruling invalidated the entire Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. His Virginia colleague didn't go that far.

If you're scoring at home, it's 2-2. That doesn't count cases entirely or partially dismissed.

Twenty-six states have sued the federal government over the mandatory purchase provision. Alaska is among them. Gov. Sean Parnell lauded the Florida decision and has refused to use federal money to prepare an insurance pool from which uninsured Alaskans could make their purchases. That decision seems more political than practical. If the provision passes constitutional muster, it would take effect in 2014. Even if you're opposed, it makes more sense to prepare for the possibility that the law will take effect as is.

To read the complete editorial, visit www.adn.com.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

We welcome comments. To post one, you must sign in using either your McClatchyDC login or your login for Facebook, Twitter or Disqus. Just click the appropriate box below.

Please keep your comment civil, short and to the point. Obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. If you find a comment abusive or inappropriate, please flag it for the moderator by placing your cursor on the comment, then clicking the "flag" link that appears. Thanks for your participation.

FEATURED COLUMNIST

leonard pitts jr.

Miami Herald columnist Leonard Pitts Jr. won the Pulitzer Prize for commentary in 2004. He is the author of the Novel, Before I Forget. Read his latest commentary here.

COMMENTARY AROUND MCCLATCHY

FEATURED COLUMNIST

joe galloway

McClatchy's veteran war correspondent, Joseph L. Galloway, retired in January 2010 after half a century in the newspaper business. Read his farewell column, and an archive of his take-no-prisoners commentary. Here's one of his most-requested columns, "Fridays at the Pentagon."