BP, feds could make millions from runaway well's oil

McClatchy NewspapersJune 3, 2010 

WASHINGTON — BP's runaway deepwater well could still become a moneymaker for the company, even as it tries to stem the gush of crude oil that's fouling the Gulf of Mexico.

If the current containment effort works — and BP and the government say they're optimistic that it will — the oil giant will salvage much of the oil that's now spewing from the crumpled pipes on the ocean floor. That captured oil, McClatchy estimates, could generate more than $1.4 million in revenue for BP each day.

Once the oil is piped to the surface to the drill ship Discoverer Enterprise, it will be processed and sent by tanker to a refinery to be sold.

"It's exactly the same as if it's normally produced oil," BP spokesman Graham MacEwen said.

Based on government estimates of the flow rate, the mangled well could produce oil valued at as much as $85 million over the next 60 days, until a relief well is complete and the well is capped permanently.

The people who own the deepwater site that's leased to BP — U.S. taxpayers — could see a more modest windfall. The Treasury could be due as much as $328,125 in royalties daily, or $19 million total over 60 days. Further, under its lease BP also must pay royalties on the oil lost in the spill, which would mean another $13.5 million.

McClatchy's calculation uses a government tally of 25,000 barrels flowing from the well each day and the 18.75 percent royalty rate applicable to oil from the BP well, and assumes that oil is selling at an average of $70 a barrel. Thursday's spot price hovered around $74.

The money that's due Uncle Sam and the added new revenue for BP from capturing the leaking oil raise many questions about the financial penalties that could be levied when something goes badly wrong with a deepwater oil well.

They also underscore the need for accurate measurements of how much oil has been flowing from the BP well since the disaster, a measurement that President Barack Obama acknowledged last week that the government was too slow to develop independently.

It remains unclear how much oil can be captured. An effort to cut the damaged pipe with a more precise diamond saw failed Wednesday, and underwater robots instead made a cruder cut Thursday with shears. So instead of the tight-fitting device the company hoped to use, it's installing a looser-fitting top hat containment dome.

Still, oil executives continue to be optimistic about capturing most of the oil once the dome is in place, said U.S. Coast Guard Adm. Thad Allen, the national incident commander for the Deepwater Horizon spill response.

"In a perfect world, we want an absolute seal, where you put two pipes together with flanges, and you bolt it so there's absolutely no way where anything can escape," Allen said. "When you're dealing with these rubber seals and an irregular fit, there's a chance that the pressure of the oil going up through the pipe will be more than the pipe can tolerate at a particular time and would spill over and maybe get out through the seals."

Getting a tally on the amount of oil that's flowing has been difficult. BP initially said the rate was 1,000 barrels a day. The government-appointed Flow Rate Technical Group put the rate at 12,000 to 25,000 barrels a day. Attaching the pumping apparatus probably would increase the flow by 20 percent.

"Obviously, when we start producing it to the ship, we will be able to more accurately tell what the rate is, but at the moment we can't tell," BP's MacEwen said. "We're pretty confident it will take the vast majority of the oil, but we can't be absolutely sure."

The Minerals Management Service wouldn't say whether BP will pay royalties to the U.S government on the oil if it's successfully captured and sent to a refinery for processing, but oil and gas lawyers and other experts in the field said there was no reason the company wouldn't pay the fees.

Nearly one in five barrels "is U.S. taxpayers' oil," said David Pursell, a managing director with the Houston-based energy investment and merchant bank Tudor, Pickering, Holt & Co.

BP's revenue from the crippled well is only a fraction of the cost of mopping up oil-soaked marshes and beaches, compensating fishermen and other business owners for lost business, and operating some of the world's most sophisticated underwater robotics in an effort to contain the spill.

BP already has paid out an estimated $1 billion, and this week the government ordered it to spend an additional $360 million to construct six barrier islands to prevent oil from reaching the Louisiana shoreline.

Nor will the revenue come close to the billions of dollars in value the publically traded company has lost as its stock has dropped 34 percent since the April 20 explosion.

Estimating the size of the spill has financial consequences for BP. From the day the rig exploded and killed 11 people, the company has underestimated how much oil is spewing from the broken well.

Accurate measurements are important because they're used as evidence when federal investigators consider fines and if juries impose damages on BP for the spill. BP also is responsible for paying royalties for each barrel of oil lost, and the measurements are needed to calculate the money that's due the government.

Federal officials continue to refine their estimates, said Jane Lubchenco, the administrator of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.

"The administration understands — for environmental, legal and financial reasons — how important it is to get good measurement of the flow rate," she said Wednesday.

So far, BP hasn't agreed with the estimates developed by the Flow Rate Technical Group, although the company has acknowledged that its initial estimates probably were low. When a riser insertion tool was in use last month before the company tried the "top kill" remedy that failed to shut down the well, BP collected about 5,000 barrels of oil daily. In total, the well produced 22,000 barrels.

No matter what, it owes the U.S. government, said Rep. Nick Rahall, D-W.Va., the chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee. He sent a letter Thursday to the Justice Department calling for it to recover any lost royalties.

The lost oil and gas "could end up costing taxpayers tens of millions of dollars in uncollected revenue," Rahall said. "I urge the department to take whatever legal action might be necessary to recoup these damages on behalf of the American public."

MORE FROM MCCLATCHY

Obama orders firms to change drill plans that mimic BP's

Oil spill takes toll on BP's credibility — and the government's

Obama calls for a price on carbon emissions

Check out McClatchy's politics blog, Planet Washington

McClatchy Newspapers 2010

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service