• Posted on Tuesday, June 1, 2010
  • Bookmark and Share
  • email
  • |
  • print
  • |
  • rss

tool name

close
tool goes here

Commentary: Honoring soldiers by opposing Fred Phelps

Fred Phelps and members of the Topeka, Kansas based Westboro Baptist Church demonstrate on Pratt Street in downtown Baltimore, Maryland.

Fred Phelps and members of the Topeka, Kansas based Westboro Baptist Church demonstrate on Pratt Street in downtown Baltimore, Maryland. | /Jed Kirschbaum / MCT

email this story print this story jump to comments

More on this Story

By the end of Wednesday, nearly all 50 states are expected to be in legal alignment against Fred Phelps.

This is no small feat. Despite the rather bland feeling an amicus brief signed by a bunch of attorney generals may elicit, the importance should be understood. Somehow, a short court document doesn't feel like much of a reply to the decades-long fury of Phelps, his crude signs about gays, the demeaning nature of his disruptive protests at the funerals of soldiers killed in Iraq and Afghanistan.

But understand that a nationally supported brief filed to the U.S. Supreme Court is likely as harsh a collective judgment that Phelps will ever receive, at least on earth.

The brief will be part of the arguments heard in October when the court takes up the case of Albert Snyder.

Snyder, of Pennsylvania, has the distinction of being the only individual to sue Phelps for picketing a funeral. Good reasons exist for why he stands alone. The toll on this man, who suffered from diabetes and severe depression before his son's death, are incalculable.

But Snyder launched his stand against Phelps after the 2006 services for his son, Lance Cpl. Matthew Snyder, a Marine who died in Iraq.

Westboro Baptist Church staged its usual funeral antics. Then, the church posted on the Internet that Snyder and his ex-wife had "taught Matthew to defy his creator, raised him for the devil and taught him that God was a liar."

Snyder sued for defamation, for invasion of privacy and for intentional infliction of emotional distress, and won $5 million in damages, only to have that judgment overturned on appeal. Defamation charges were dismissed.

Because Phelps calls Topeka home, Kansas Attorney General Steve Six led the effort, writing the brief. Then Six's office got busy, pressuring other states to step up.

With Thursday's deadline looming, a full-court press was applied Wednesday. Thirteen more states, including Missouri, signed on. That brought the total to 43 states, plus the District of Columbia.

Six's plea is that the court, in its ruling, should be careful to not undermine the laws of Kansas and many other states that try to restrict Phelps' impact on the grieving — usually limited to how close the protesters can get to funerals and gravesites. The brief reminds the justices of Phelps' "particularly intrusive and harassing form of speech."

Memorial Day weekend: The timing is a fluke, but it couldn't be more appropriate.

No one has done more to dishonor soldiers than Phelps and his odd little family of followers.

The least the states can do is stand firmly against Phelps' message and yet honor the liberties the soldiers died defending, the constitutional right of a person to be so repugnant.

  • Bookmark and Share
  • email
  • |
  • print
  • |
  • rss

tool name

close
tool goes here
JOIN THE DISCUSSION

We welcome comments. To post one, you must sign in using either your McClatchyDC login or your login for Facebook, Twitter or Disqus. Just click the appropriate box below.

Please keep your comment civil, short and to the point. Obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. If you find a comment abusive or inappropriate, please flag it for the moderator by placing your cursor on the comment, then clicking the "flag" link that appears. Thanks for your participation.

Stay Connected

Sign up for email newsletters RSS
Follow us on your iPhone Follow us on your Android device
Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us using Google Currents

FEATURED COLUMNIST

leonard pitts jr.

Miami Herald columnist Leonard Pitts Jr. won the Pulitzer Prize for commentary in 2004. He is the author of the Novel, Before I Forget. Read his latest commentary here.

COMMENTARY AROUND MCCLATCHY

FEATURED COLUMNIST

joe galloway

McClatchy's veteran war correspondent, Joseph L. Galloway, retired in January 2010 after half a century in the newspaper business. Read his farewell column, and an archive of his take-no-prisoners commentary. Here's one of his most-requested columns, "Fridays at the Pentagon."