Man convicted in 1999 rape case filed against his DNA profile

January 29, 2010 

KANSAS CITY — The case against whoever raped 81-year-old Carol Cooper in 1999 originally was filed against an anonymous "John Doe," identifiable only by his DNA profile.

But on Thursday a Jackson County jury decided that Terry U. Birmingham was responsible.

Jurors convicted Birmingham, 43, of forcible rape, assault and burglary in the Christmas Eve attack. They acquitted him of robbery and an additional rape charge.

Cooper told police that a stranger followed her into her Kansas City home after she took Christmas cookies to a neighbor. The stranger beat and raped her, trial evidence showed.

Though the trial took only three days, the case has a 10-year history rich in mystery and legal complication.

The case prompted an important change in Missouri criminal law, lost a key witness when Cooper disappeared six years ago and highlighted changing methods of DNA evidence collection, storage, testing and interpretation.

Without a victim to identify her attacker — Cooper left her home for a walk in September 2004 and never returned — the case against Birmingham depended heavily on decade-old DNA evidence.

Because investigators did not have a suspect’s name early on, prosecutors filed charges against an unknown “John Doe” in 2002, before the statute of limitations expired. They identified him only with the DNA profile developed from evidence taken from Cooper.

This case marked the first time Jackson County prosecutors used the John Doe technique. Since then the office has filed more than a dozen such cases.

The Missouri General Assembly later changed state law to exempt forcible rape and sodomy from a three-year statute of limitations.

In August 2007, prosecutors amended the charges to identify Birmingham. He had been convicted that year of burglary and resisting arrest. As he was booked into a Missouri prison, authorities took a DNA sample from him that matched evidence from Cooper’s rape, authorities said.

Read the full story at KansasCity.com

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service