One industry that's booming: debt collection

McClatchy NewspapersOctober 15, 2009 

WASHINGTON -- In the often murky waters of the debt collection industry, United Recovery Systems in Houston is considered a "whale hunter."

In its search for clients, United isn't looking for mom-and-pop businesses with a few hundred deadbeat customers. It wants bigger fish.

Its client roster includes national banks, international credit card issuers and domestic and foreign auto finance giants, each of whom count on United to make good on their bad accounts.

In the current economic climate, the "whales" are virtually jumping out of the water and into United's boat. The company is taking in $937 million a month in new accounts, compared with about $550 million a month last year, said United's marketing director, Sean Keegan.

After beginning the year with 1,200 debt collectors, United has added 300 and will add another 300 by year's end.

"The volume was so huge that we had to run out and hire collectors," Keegan said. "I can't put 5,000 accounts in this guy's file box for him to work this month. I have to go hire new people."

United's growth spurt isn't an aberration. Across the country, dozens of established collection agencies are expanding their operations and hiring collectors, managers and support staff to keep up with the rising tide of bad debt due to massive job losses.

As real estate values fall, homeowners can no longer tap their home equity to pay down debt. So antsy creditors are farming out more problem accounts to collectors after declaring them as charge-offs, or losses.

With billions of dollars outstanding on millions of past due accounts, creditors want their money now and collection agencies with a track record of success are cashing in.

"As banks scramble to bring in money, they're going to go with the companies they feel most safe with," said Patrick Lunsford, the senior editor at InsideARM.com, which chronicles the accounts receivable industry. "They're not going to spend a lot of time trying out new collection agencies, so companies with the strongest business relationships are getting the work."

Last week, Financial Management Systems opened a 350-person call center in Rockford, Ill. Thirty-four people are already employed, and 100 will be on board by year's end.

Last month, Windham Professionals announced plans to add 140 employees to its 60-person operation in East Aurora, N.Y.

In Texarkana, Ark., West Asset Management recently added 100 new customer service employees to contact homeowners on the verge of foreclosure. Premiere Credit of North America just opened a second operations center in Indianapolis and began a $4 million expansion of its headquarters there.

Premiere, which specializes in student loan collections and government debt from traffic tickets to back taxes, bumped its workforce from 250 in January to 361 in August. It expects to employ more than 500 people in a few years.

The extra work has been a mixed blessing for the industry. There's more opportunity, but recovery rates are down because it's harder to collect during a recession when people don't have as much money.

"So it becomes a very tight management drill where agencies have to get enough collectors to work the accounts but, at the same time, to remain profitable, they have to bring more money in," Lunsford said.

United uses complicated mathematic scoring models to determine the 20 percent of accounts that will pay 80 percent of their debt, Keegan said. Those accounts go to their best collectors. Similar predictive software helps companies better gauge their recovery rates and make sound hiring decisions.

Many agencies miscalculate, however, and end up expending more on new employees than they attract in new revenue. A recent survey of collection firms by InsideARM.com found that roughly one-third had eliminated positions or laid off workers in the second quarter, up from 26 percent in the first quarter.

Lunsford said many reported that they were "spending more money to collect less."

Wary of that dynamic and the uncertain economy, IC System in St. Paul, Minn., has slowed its hiring after adding about 300 employees over the last few years, said the company's president and chief executive, Ken Rapp. Lower collection rates also have forced Rapp to terminate clients whose accounts weren't profitable.

He said collections usually improve this time of year when summer and back-to-school spending subsides. But this year, that trend has faltered.

"We're seeing a modest improvement', but not like we normally see," Rapp said.

For consumers, one benefit of the troubled economy is that more creditors are willing to accept payment plan arrangements and debt settlements for a portion of outstanding account balances.

"They figure they're better off getting something than nothing," Rapp explained. "So we try to be more accommodating on setting up payment plans that we tended to stay away from when the economy was a little better."

ON THE WEB

For government report on debt collection practices

MORE FROM MCCLATCHY

For the long-term unemployed, recovery talk rings hollow

Economy's plunge forcing more kids into school lunch plans

Americans are getting poorer, and it's going to get worse

Bankruptcy filings drop, giving hope of recovering economy

McClatchy Newspapers 2009

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service