Palin won't make public her 'troopergate' testimony

Anchorage Daily NewsDecember 5, 2008 

As far as Gov. Sarah Palin is concerned, "troopergate" is behind her and she won't provide a transcript of testimony she gave in an investigation into whether she violated ethics laws in firing her public safety commissioner, Walt Monegan.

Palin has maintained she did nothing wrong and that Monegan was dismissed for reasons unrelated to her concerns about her ex-brother-in-law, Trooper Michael Wooten. She had called Wooten a "trooper time-bomb" and complained to Monegan in an e-mail that Wooten had tasered his stepson, drank in his patrol car, and shot a moose without a permit, and yet was still on the street.

Her husband, Todd, as well as officials in her administration, pressured Monegan and others at the Department of Public Safety about Wooten. Monegan has said he believes he was fired in part because he wouldn't get rid of Wooten, and one investigation into the matter came to the same conclusion.

Palin cooperated with only one of two investigations into the circumstances of Monegan's dismissal, the one by the state Personnel Board, which she said was the proper venue for an ethics investigation and which cleared her, not the separate investigation by the state Legislature, which found she abused her power by failing to rein in Todd and others, but still had the right to fire Monegan.

When the Personnel Board investigation began, Palin said she wanted it made public.

"The people of Alaska -- and of the nation -- deserve to have a decision from the proper tribunal putting their minds at ease that suggestions of misconduct that have circulated on the Internet and in some media outlets are not true. I therefore am waiving the confidentiality that usually covers personnel board complaints," Palin said in a statement released by her lawyer, Thomas Van Flein, on Sept. 2, just days after she was named John McCain's running mate.

She gave her only testimony in the matter on Oct. 24 while on the vice presidential campaign trail. Van Flein said at the time that she wanted to release a transcript of her deposition. Reached Thursday evening, Van Flein said he hadn't talked to Palin about releasing it since then. "That's their call, I guess," he said.

Palin is simply ready to move on, her deputy press secretary, Sharon Leighow, wrote in an e-mail exchange this week.

"This matter is closed. We see no public purpose in artificially prolonging this controversy," she wrote initially.

Then, Leighow went a bit further:

"Governor Palin waived her confidentiality to release the Personnel Board report — not her deposition. Two investigations concerning this matter have been conducted and concluded; we are not going to relitigate this in the media now. The politics are over and behind us. In both investigations, the investigators found that the Governor acted with her proper and lawful authority in dismissing Walt Monegan. We are moving forward now and not looking back at a matter, which has distracted Alaskans from the key issues at hand; the price of oil, the state of our budget, and resource development in Alaska, including the ultimate construction of a natural gas pipeline."

The governor's office also refused to release a transcript of Todd Palin's deposition and other key documents that were part of the Personnel Board investigation, but not included as attachments to the official report.

The governor's office wouldn't provide copies of e-mails, some to Sarah or Todd, that were sent in the days before an infamous call by Palin aide Frank Bailey to a trooper lieutenant about Wooten. In the call, which was recorded, Bailey said "Todd and Sarah are scratching their heads. You know, why on Earth hasn't, why is this guy still representing the department?" Palin has said she never authorized the call. The e-mails are not public because of reasons including "executive privilege," "the governor's office said.

The governor's office also declined to release notes from a meeting of Palin administration officials in which Wooten's return to work after an injury was discussed. The notes relate to a confidential personnel matter, the governor's office said.

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service