Denver-bound Edwards delegates ask, What if he'd won?

Charlotte ObserverAugust 19, 2008 

From her front row seat at the 2004 national convention, delegate Linda Gunter led the cheers when fellow North Carolina Democrat John Edwards accepted the vice presidential nomination.

The former teacher from Cary, N.C., had spent a month trudging through the snows of New Hampshire for him.

Now, like other Carolinas delegates to next week's Democratic convention, she's dismayed by revelations about Edwards' affair with a former campaign worker.

"My bubble of enthusiasm for presidential politics was really deflated," says Gunter, 58. "Some people might get discouraged from getting involved because they really believed in him, and he let them down."

On Aug. 8, Edwards acknowledged an affair with Rielle Hunter but denied tabloid reports of a "love child" and elaborate cover-up. His admission disappointed many Democrats and served as a distraction as presumed nominee Barack Obama tries to ensure a united and enthusiastic party at next week's convention in Denver.

Reactions from three-dozen Carolinas delegates range from outrage to continued support.

Edwards says the affair ended in 2006. Some are bothered by the fact that he continued to campaign for president, even after the National Enquirer reported it last October.

"There is a feeling that it was very selfish of him to pursue the presidency knowing that this skeleton was in his closet," says Vinod Thomas, 32, of Cornelius. "The Democratic Party would be in a very tough position now if John Edwards was our nominee."

When Edwards dropped out of the 2008 race in January, Charlotte delegate Marc Friedland switched his support to Sen. Hillary Clinton of New York. Now he wonders if Edwards' presence cost Clinton the nomination. Edwards finished behind Obama but beat Clinton in January's Iowa caucuses.

"If Edwards had not been in the Iowa (caucuses), it's very likely that Hillary would have won," says Friedland, 59.

At a Charlotte book-signing last year, Friedland asked Edwards what it takes to get good people to run for office. Edwards talked about character.

"He was saying that while he knew very well what was going on in his own life," Friedland says. "He was reckless … delusional."

Retired teacher Susan Campbell, 56, of Winston-Salem was an Edwards delegate in 2004. She liked his description of "two Americas" and his apparent commitment to fighting poverty.

"I just expected he believed all those things," she says. "I didn't expect him to be so caught up in himself. It's not just the affair, it's the cover-up. We don't know the truth."

Democrats don't expect the scandal to affect other races. Neither does John Hood, president of the John Locke Foundation, a conservative Raleigh think tank.

"I certainly know some Democrats who feel personally outraged," he says. "But they're a lot more angry at George W. Bush than they are at John Edwards or the National Enquirer or anybody else."

The revelations won't stop South Carolina delegate Mike Evatt from wearing his Edwards' T-shirt in Denver. He's bringing two.

Evatt, 45, works in a plant in Seneca, where Edwards was born. In 2004 and 2008, he ran Edwards' Oconee County campaigns. And when Evatt's wife, Kelly, died from a sudden heart attack last month, John and Elizabeth Edwards were the first to send flowers.

Their peace lily still sits in the sunlight of his dining room.

"Just because he made a mistake over two years ago don't give me a right to be ashamed of him," Evatt says. "He and Elizabeth are my friends. You're not very much of a friend if you turn your back … when they have trouble."

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service