8-06-07 Ex-priest takes on Paraguay's entrenched ruling party

McClatchy NewspapersAugust 6, 2007 

ASUNCION, Paraguay — For 60 years, Paraguay's Colorado Party has used political patronage — as well as fraud and violence — to remain in control of the country, longer than any other political party in the world that's still in power.

Now Fernando Lugo, 48, a country priest with no previous political experience, appears poised to bring that long run to an end.

This ascendancy reflects a region-wide trend toward rejecting long-ruling political elites that have failed to deliver better standards of living to Latin America's poor.

In 2000, Mexico's Institutional Revolutionary Party, which was then the world's longest ruling, lost its first presidential election in more than 70 years. After that, former union head Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva became Brazil's first president of working-class origins, Bolivia elected its first indigenous leader and socially conservative Chile chose its first female president.

"Political parties all over Latin America are in crisis because they haven't responded to the social demands of Latin Americans," Lugo said during an interview with McClatchy Newspapers in his office in a working-class neighborhood of the Paraguayan capital, Asuncion.

Lugo won the endorsement of Paraguay's top six opposition parties July 18. If the coalition holds, he seems likely to wrest control of the country next spring from the Colorado Party, which has long been seen as inseparable from the government.

"If you're sick, it's faster to come to the party office than to the hospital," Sady Yuvero, 33 and a party employee, said to explain the party's hold on Paraguay. "That way, you know you'll get to see a doctor."

In Paraguay, party chieftains run everything from the power company to the police department. Receiving basic services often means first asking the neighborhood Colorado office for help.

"The Colorado Party in its long history has run its government machine and run the electoral judicial system and used state properties for political campaigns, but it's a model that's worn out," Lugo said. "In 60 years, it didn't give a satisfactory response to the big social needs of the country."

With less than nine months to go before the vote April 20, Lugo's presidential victory is far from secure, however. Political coalitions such as the one that's backing him, known as Concertacion, have fallen apart before on the eve of elections.

The Colorados, who control the country's electoral court and Supreme Court, also are expected to argue that Lugo's status as a priest bans him from holding elected office under the constitution.

Lugo announced last December that he'd left the priesthood, but the Vatican hasn't officially released him from his duties.

Still, the Colorados, who'll choose their candidate at the end of the year, could lose, political columnist Alfredo Boccia Paz said.

"If there's a coalition backing him, Lugo wins," Boccia Paz said. "That's what the polls say now."

Paraguay has long been known as a landlocked backwater and a haven for smugglers, Nazi war criminals and religious outcasts. With 6.7 million residents, it's one of the poorest countries in the Western Hemisphere and one of the region's most economically divided. Nearly half the population lives in poverty.

Despite the dismal numbers, Sen. Martin Chiola, the Colorado Party's vice leader in the senate, said the party deserved credit for steering the country through a civil war, the Cold War and all manner of political turmoil. Colorado governments include the brutal 35-year rule of dictator Alfredo Stroessner.

"It's a national feeling," Chiola said. "The Colorado Party was born with the nation itself, the only folkloric party. It was launched by Paraguayans, and its ideology is eminently Paraguayan."

Most Paraguayans know the party not for its center-right ideology, however, but for its presence in practically every corner of public life.

For years, public-sector jobs went only to party members, which encouraged governments to build enormous bureaucracies that functioned as campaign machines, Boccia Paz said. He estimated that some 200,000 people work in the public sector.

"They are like electoral soldiers for the Colorado Party," he said. "The lack of alternation in power, which is very important in a democracy, meant that no one challenged the structure of the party becoming the same as the state's."

Bus driver Ismail Moran, who lives just outside the capital, said he'd been fired from government jobs for criticizing the Colorados.

"We're looking for change," said Moran, who's 45. "It's possible now because people are finally waking up."

Lugo's rise has been helped by his reputation as a political outsider who spent years championing social causes in the country's most impoverished district, San Pedro, in central Paraguay.

Tall and charismatic, he was first spotted as presidential material last year when he addressed an opposition rally of 50,000 people who'd gathered to protest President Nicanor Duarte Frutos' plan to amend the constitution so that he could seek re-election. The speech was only eight minutes long, but by its end Lugo, whose family had long been opposed to Colorado rule, had become the leading opposition figure, Boccia Paz said.

What Lugo would do as president is the subject of speculation. The Colorados have accused him of being a radical socialist and friends with the convicted killers of the daughter of a former president, allegations that he denies. Some suggest that he'd ally himself with regional leftist leaders, such as Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez and Bolivian President Evo Morales, who've harshly criticized the Bush administration.

Lugo was vague about his agenda in the interview. He said his priorities would include cleaning up Paraguay's corrupt justice system, launching an agrarian reform program and strengthening the rule of law to attract more investment.

He suggests that discussing his ideology is a throwback to a different time.

"It's a discussion from the 1970s," he said. "We just need bread, and it doesn't matter whether it's from the right or the left hand."

McClatchy Newspapers 2007

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service