Transplant surgeon charged with 3 felonies

The Tribune, San Luis Obispo, Calif.July 30, 2007 

SAN LUIS OBISPO, Calif. — San Luis Obispo County prosecutors charged a San Francisco transplant surgeon with three felonies Monday, alleging he attempted to hasten the death of a 26-year-old disabled man last year at Sierra Vista Regional Medical Center in an attempt to harvest his organs.

Prosecutors are charging Dr. Hootan Roozrokh, 33, with dependent adult abuse, administering a harmful substance, Betadine, and unlawful prescribing of sedatives to a severely disabled man, Ruben Navarro.

If convicted of all charges he could face up to eight years in prison.

Roozrokh was expected to turn himself in Tuesday and post bail. His arraignment date had not yet been set.

The surgeon's attorney, M. Gerald Schwartzbach, issued a statement Monday saying Roozrokh committed no crime and has "unfairly been the subject of an 18-month witch hunt."

The local case is the first of its kind against a transplant surgeon and has vast implications for the nation's organ donor system because it casts doubts on organ donation after cardiac death, or heart failure. That's less common than donation after brain death, but increasingly seen as a way to help alleviate the national organ shortage.

In 2006, for example, organs were recovered from 645 donors nationwide after cardiac death, representing 8 percent of all deceased donors. That's up from 189 in 2002.

Prosecutors allege that Roozrokh violated the law on Feb. 3, 2006, when he took control of Navarro's care before he was dead, and that he mistreated him by ordering excessive amounts of sedatives "to accelerate Mr. Navarro's death in order to recover his organs," a statement said.

Navarro's organs were not harvested because he did not die within 30 minutes — the timeframe under which his organs remained viable for transplant.

"The central issue of the case is the mistreatment of a person who was still alive," said Stephen Brown, chief deputy district attorney.

"We know that there are social and political implications, but we're trying to be low-key and treat it like any other case," Brown said.

Donation after cardiac death is more complex and controversial than donation after brain death, when the patient has already been declared legally dead before being removed from breathing machines.

In the former situation, once a patient is removed from machines and declared dead due to heart failure, there is only a five-minute interval to observe death before surgeons begin recovering organs.

Cardiac death donations fall within ethical guidelines if strict protocols are followed.

The medical community's paramount rules and state law say that transplant surgeons should have no contact with the patient until the attending physician declares death and any attempts to hasten death are prohibited.

An alleged breach of those protocols led to the charges against Roozrokh.

Navarro was taken by ambulance to Sierra Vista on Jan. 29, 2006, after he was found in a coma at the residential care home where he lived in San Luis Obispo.

The patient, who at 10 was diagnosed with a rare degenerative disease, was placed on life support, but not declared brain dead because he had minimal brain function. Navarro's mother then agreed to donate his organs, according to a police investigation.

The Oakland, Calif.-based Organ Transplant Donor Network dispatched a surgical team, which included Roozrokh, from San Francisco to recover Navarro's organs.

Navarro was taken into the operating room and removed from life support, but he did not die within 30 minutes.

Violating the hospital's protocol and state law, Roozrokh took over caring for Navarro before he was declared dead and ordered a nurse to give Navarro abnormally high doses of morphine and Ativan to hasten death, according to an investigation by the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

Prosecutors also allege that Roozrokh injected Betadine, a topical antiseptic, into Navarro's stomach.

The attempted organ donation occurred on a Friday night. Navarro died the next day at 8 a.m. Operating room nursing staff alerted hospital administrators the following Monday about the incident. The hospital then notified police and state and federal health officials.

None of the other six nurses, doctors and technicians who were in the operating room and did not intervene will face criminal charges, Brown said.

San Luis Obispo police turned the case over to the county District Attorney's Office in March. The rare circumstances and the fact that there is no case precedent slowed the investigation, prosecutor Brown said.

"Dr. Roozrokh and his wife have suffered immeasurably as a result of the dissemination of false accusations and the interminable delay in the investigation of this case," according to the statement from his attorney.

Ruben's mother, Rosa Navarro, filed a wrongful death suit on June 29 in San Luis Obispo Superior Court, alleging she never gave hospital officials consent to take her son off life-support and was misinformed when agreeing to the organ harvest.

The criminal proceedings will greatly impact her civil case, said her attorney, Kevin Chaffin.

"The fact that the prosecutors have stood up to the medical community and carried this forward ... has done a lot to validate her feelings that she and Ruben were mistreated," Chaffin said.

Roozrokh has been a Kaiser Permanente physician since 2005. He has voluntarily not been seeing patients for the past several months, and as of Monday is on administrative leave, according to a statement by Kaiser officials.

The California Medical Board and the state Attorney General's office are also investigating Roozrokh's involvement in the attempted organ donation, medical board spokeswoman Candis Cohen said.

David Heneghan, spokesman for the California Transplant Donor Network, said the agency does not believe the criminal charges will discourage future donors. Sierra Vista has revised its policies and retrained its staff on organ donation since the incident, hospital spokesman Ron Yukelson said. The hospital will no longer perform organ donations after cardiac death and will refer those cases out to other hospitals, he said.


(c) 2007, The Tribune, San Luis Obispo, Calif.

Visit The Tribune Online at

Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

McClatchy Newspapers 2007

McClatchy Washington Bureau is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service